Sherlock Holmes and the Mathematics of Murder: A Case Study
Written on
Chapter 1: A Snowy Day in London
On a cold winter day in London, Sherlock Holmes lay in bed, contemplating yet another puzzling case. His thoughts were interrupted by Dr. Watson's arrival, who presented a rather strange murder mystery. Initially indifferent, Sherlock's interest piqued when Watson mentioned bicycle tracks left by the culprit. "Let’s examine those tracks," Sherlock proposed, and upon arriving at the scene, he was greeted with a perplexing sight—he too could not discern the tracks' direction.
Even as others retreated to their warm homes, Sherlock remained fixated on deciphering the unusual tracks. The evidence showed two distinct tire tracks, likely from a front and rear tire. He realized that understanding which track belonged to which tire was crucial for determining the escape route of the suspect.
The first video, "Talks - Gajendra Deshpande: Three Musketeers: Sherlock Holmes, Mathematics and Python," delves into the intricate relationship between mathematics and the legendary detective, showcasing how mathematical concepts underpin his investigative methods.
Chapter 2: Delving into Mathematics
Returning to his study, Sherlock rummaged through his extensive library for mathematical texts that could provide insights into his quandary, focusing on geometry and the newly emerging field of calculus. Hours later, he immersed himself in the study of differential curves, which were crucial to understanding the peculiarities of the tire tracks.
He soon discovered that the tire tracks indicated an interdependent movement of the front and rear tires, which were designed to maintain a fixed distance from one another. But how did this principle manifest in reality?
Sherlock recalled observing his pocket watch—when he moved its chain, the watch followed but never quite reached the chain's end. This phenomenon, known in mathematics as the tractrix, described a path approaching an asymptote without ever touching it.
The second video, "How Sherlock Solved This Curious Case," illustrates how Holmes applied mathematical reasoning to solve complex mysteries, including the importance of understanding motion and geometry.
Section 2.1: The Nature of the Tractrix
Through his studies, Sherlock grasped that the bicycle's tire tracks mirrored the behavior of the pocket watch and its chain. Both the front and rear tires moved in synchrony, and this relationship was evident in the tractrix's dual branches. Upon drawing tangent lines from specific points on the tractrix, he found a remarkable correlation: the lengths of these tangents matched the distance between the bicycle's tires on the ground, known as the wheelbase.
Despite the mathematical abstraction, real-world physics complicated things. The tires did not behave perfectly, and a cyclist's steering would inevitably produce varied tracks.
Section 2.2: Identifying the Tracks
Sherlock noted that when the front tire oscillated, the rear tire did so with a reduced amplitude, allowing him to determine which tracks belonged to which tire. He was on the verge of solving the case, but the next step was to ascertain the bicycle's direction.
By selecting random points from the rear tire's track and drawing tangent lines towards the front, he could predict the bicycle’s path. If all tangent lines were equal, the bicycle had moved in that direction; if not, it had veered the opposite way.
However, an intriguing thought crossed his mind: what if the tangent lines were equal in both directions? According to Newton, that was indeed a possibility.
Sherlock concluded with a grin—he understood the bicycle’s trajectory and was confident he could deduce the identity of the murderer.
Conclusion: The Mathematical Mind of Sherlock Holmes
In conclusion, analyzing bicycle tracks can be an engaging intellectual exercise. First, one must identify the rear tire based on its unique oscillation pattern. Then, by drawing tangent lines towards the front tire, one can determine the direction of travel. This method, while simplified, provides valuable insights into the underlying mathematical principles at play.
The real world may present complexities that deviate from these models, but they still illuminate the connections between mathematics and everyday phenomena.
Acknowledgments:
I would like to express my gratitude to Simon Foundations for the enlightening video about bicycle tracks that inspired this article. Special thanks to my diligent student, Mucteba Karaca, for editing my work.
Note 1: Don't forget to subscribe to "Beyond Euclid!" for high-quality math and science insights.
Note 2: I may earn commissions from purchases made through links in this content.