Chapter 1: The Rise of AI and Its Implications

Since its launch in November 2022, ChatGPT has significantly transformed how we perceive AI's capabilities. It can generate text, write code, and perform numerous tasks that were once the domain of humans. This duality of excitement and concern surrounds generative AI technology. While humans can still excel in many areas, the future remains uncertain.

Despite my reservations about AI-generated content, it's undeniable that such material is rapidly filling the web. As an SEO professional, I must grasp how AI will reshape our field and the consequences of its content on SEO practices.

Interestingly, many discussions around AI-driven content creation happen without a solid understanding of the technology behind it. A particularly amusing post on LinkedIn proclaimed the end of paid SEO tools due to ChatGPT plugins revolutionizing the SEO landscape. However, upon reviewing the comments, it became clear that the author hadn't even tested the recommended plugins!

Chapter 2: The Reality Check

Despite the hype, I’ve noticed that social media influencers rarely share tangible results from using AI-generated content. It's unclear whether they have achieved their business objectives through these methods. Furthermore, no substantial studies exist to validate the effects of AI on SEO.

As I noted in a previous article, Google does not oppose the use of AI-generated content—provided it isn't used to manipulate search rankings. Yet, numerous website owners are leveraging ChatGPT and Bard to create content they believe will surpass their competitors in organic search rankings.

One client of mine aggressively employed AI-generated content on their site, asserting that the quality matched that of their human copywriters. While I agree that ChatGPT might replace entry-level and some mid-tier writers lacking niche expertise, I question the value of mere paraphrasing. In my view, it holds little to no value.

However, I undertook an experiment with AI content to evaluate its impact on SEO and organic search performance. You can read about the findings of that experiment later in this article.

The first video, "8 Steps To Improve SEO Content Writing With ChatGPT," provides insightful methods for optimizing content using AI tools.

The second video, "FULL GUIDE to Use ChatGPT to Write a GOOD Article FAST," offers a comprehensive guide on effectively using ChatGPT for fast article writing.

Section 2.1: Limitations of ChatGPT in Content Creation

This section delves into what ChatGPT struggled to comprehend and execute during the content creation and optimization phases.

1. Inability to Assess Keyword Difficulty

   Relying on ChatGPT or Bard for keyword difficulty analysis is unwise. AI chatbots lack the necessary understanding to accurately evaluate what factors should be considered in this analysis. Even when using plugins to connect ChatGPT to the Internet, it falls short in assessing the competition level for a given keyword. To clarify, keyword difficulty typically ranges from 0 to 100, as determined by tools like Ahrefs, Moz, or Semrush to aid SEO professionals in making informed decisions. Unfortunately, my expectation for valuable insights from ChatGPT was met with disappointment.

2. Unreliable Keyword Analysis

   If you attempt to use ChatGPT for SEO, as many "influencers" suggest, you'll encounter numerous inconsistencies and unreliable information. Experienced SEO professionals can quickly identify the shortcomings in ChatGPT's responses, but this may be less apparent to newcomers. In one instance, ChatGPT incorrectly indicated that my keyword had low competition; while this was indeed true, relying solely on assumptions is perilous.

3. Failure to Adhere to Requested Word Count

   I encountered a recurring issue where ChatGPT could only generate 600 words at a time, which proved frustrating. In contrast, the upgraded ChatGPT-4 can produce over 25,000 words in a single go. Nevertheless, users must remain vigilant about output length, as ChatGPT can sometimes fall short of the requested word count.

4. Need for Fact-Checking

   Research is often a time-consuming part of content creation, which is why I hoped to expedite the process by using AI chatbots. I expected ChatGPT to compile a list of sources I would otherwise have to gather manually. However, I found that its statements and source links were frequently unrelated. For instance, one link led to a 404 error, indicating that the page no longer existed. Relying on ChatGPT for data gathering is risky; thorough fact-checking is essential to ensure that the generated content is reliable.

5. Limited Selection of Advanced Learning Resources

   While the Internet is brimming with beginner-level resources across various fields, finding advanced materials can be challenging. As an SEO specialist, I've spent considerable time searching for high-level articles, studies, and courses to enhance my knowledge. I asked ChatGPT to recommend advanced SEO resources, but its suggestions consisted of well-known websites that cater primarily to beginners. This response was of little help for someone looking to deepen their expertise.

In Summary

AI chatbots are now a vital component of our content production workflow. Despite their inaccuracies and lack of engaging writing, content creators will continue to depend on AI generators to enhance their output. My research indicates that ChatGPT cannot replace human SEO efforts, regardless of the prompts or plugins used. It may suggest keywords and provide volume estimates, but these should not be the sole basis for business decisions. Specialized SEO tools remain irreplaceable.

The proliferation of misleading information poses an increasing challenge unless content creators commit to thorough fact-checking. Remember, it is your duty to deliver trustworthy, valuable information to your audience. Relying entirely on AI to perform our roles could lead to a significant decline in quality. Instead, we should view it as a supportive tool to alleviate some of our workload.

? Grab my guide to learn how I create blog posts that achieve top rankings on Google.

? Interested in expanding your SEO knowledge? Join my free email course.