Chapter 1: Understanding Woolly Mammoth Extinction

Recent investigations have reignited an age-old debate about the woolly mammoth's extinction. Did humans hunt them to oblivion, or was it climate change that sealed their fate? This discussion has evolved with new analyses shedding light on the mammoth's extensive migration across North America and the circumstances of its demise.

Let’s rewind time slightly to examine the consensus among researchers. Woolly mammoths were remarkably adapted to the frigid conditions of the Ice Age, sporting a thick layer of fat and a shaggy coat. Standing as tall as 12 feet (3.7 meters) and weighing up to 16,000 pounds (7,300 kg)—equivalent to four average vehicles—they roamed vast areas, including present-day Europe, Eurasia, and North America, extending as far south as Los Angeles and Miami.

Until about 11,700 years ago, during the Pleistocene epoch, the Earth was significantly colder and drier, fostering the growth of tundra vegetation—grasses, shrubs, and herbs—which the mammoths thrived on. Meanwhile, early humans also found value in these majestic creatures, hunting them for meat and using their hides and tusks for various purposes.

As the climate transitioned to warmer and wetter conditions, marking the beginning of the Holocene epoch, vast glaciers receded. Grasslands transformed into wetlands and forests, fragmenting the mammoth's habitat. The increased snowfall during winter made mobility challenging for these large mammals.

However, contrary to previous beliefs, mammoths did not vanish overnight. This has led to contrasting viewpoints on the extinction's primary cause.

Human Actions or Natural Changes?

“Debates have raged for a century regarding the woolly mammoth's extinction,” remarked Eske Willerslev, PhD, an ecology and evolution professor at the University of Cambridge. “Humans have often been held responsible since these creatures survived millions of years of climate shifts, only to decline rapidly once humans arrived.”

In October 2021, Willerslev and his team presented findings indicating that humans might not be to blame after all.

“We have conclusively shown that the speed of climate change, rather than just the change itself, was a critical factor in their extinction,” Willerslev stated. “Mammoths struggled to adapt quickly as their environment dramatically shifted, leading to a scarcity of food.”

In a subsequent study, another group utilizing ancient DNA and modern computational models determined that the extinction process spanned approximately 20,000 years, with humans accelerating the decline during the final 4,000 years.

“Our research indicates that humans played a significant role in the gradual decline of woolly mammoths, affecting the timing and locations of their extinction,” asserted Damien Fordham, PhD, an associate professor of global change ecology at the University of Adelaide.

Moreover, research from McMaster University in December 2021 uncovered evidence of mammoths in Canadian permafrost dating as recently as 5,000 years ago, much later than previously believed.

In his bestselling 2023 book, The World: A Family History of Humanity, historian Simon Sebag Montefiore briefly summarizes the situation, stating that by around 10,000 years ago, “human hunting and forest management began driving large mammals—including mammoths and mastodons—to extinction.”

A Balanced Perspective

“Ice Age megafauna enthusiasts often align with either the 'overkill' or 'climate change' camps, but the reality is more complex,” suggests Audrey Rowe, a researcher at the University of Alaska Fairbanks who led a study at the 14,000-year-old Swan Point archaeological site in Alaska.

Analyzing a tusk from a female woolly mammoth, affectionately named Elma, provided insights into her diet and migratory patterns as she traversed 620 miles (1,000 kilometers) through Alaska and Canada. Elma met her end at Swan Point, near the remains of two juvenile mammoths and an apparent hunting camp, complete with evidence of a fire and stone tools used for butchering.

“She wandered into a region rich in archaeological sites,” Rowe noted. “It appears that early humans established hunting camps in areas frequented by mammoths.”

Elma was a healthy adult when she perished during the active hunting season. Rowe and her team pieced together evidence to create a more nuanced narrative around woolly mammoth extinction, particularly in one region.

“I believe that mammoths faced a grim future in Alaska following the Pleistocene,” Rowe explained. “The wetter Holocene climate was incompatible with their preferred grass and herb tundra. Without the additional pressure of human hunting, they might have survived as a small relic population, but their fate was still uncertain.”

The findings, published on January 17, 2024, in Science Advances, suggest a clear link between human hunting and mammoth extinction at Swan Point. “Even if mammoths were already in decline, human actions certainly expedited their extinction,” Rowe stated.

The extinction of these magnificent creatures serves as a poignant reminder of the vulnerability of large species, particularly in the face of climate change and human influence.

“The loss of the mammoth highlights a critical lesson: larger animals are often more susceptible to extinction during times of ecological upheaval,” Rowe remarked. “This pattern is evident throughout history, explaining why non-avian dinosaurs vanished while smaller mammals and birds thrived.”

Large animals tend to mature and reproduce at a slower rate, making recovery from population declines challenging, whether caused by climate shifts or human encroachment. This poses a significant threat to many of today's endangered species, including gorillas, elephants, rhinos, and whales.

“Our planet's history indicates that large species can reach a point of no return alarmingly quickly,” Rowe concluded.

Epilogue: Rethinking Prehistoric Humans

In a discussion about the insights gained during her research journey, Rowe reflected on how her perceptions of prehistoric humans have evolved. She noted the common stereotype of primitive Stone Age individuals as simplistic “unga bunga” cavemen, reminiscent of scenes from 2001: A Space Odyssey.

However, as she delved deeper, Rowe recognized that these ancient people were incredibly intelligent and resourceful, spending considerable time teaching their offspring essential survival skills.

“I aim to reshape the public's perception of prehistoric humans, moving away from the simplistic ‘unga bunga’ narrative,” she stated. The artist rendering commissioned by her team depicts an adult mammoth with two younger mammoths, observed by a family of humans. This imagery intends to represent a learning moment for children about the magnificent creatures they shared their environment with, featuring a woman and children—elements often overlooked in paleo-art.

Admittedly, this perspective is somewhat contradictory, as Swan Point was indeed a hunting site, resulting in the death of mammoths.

Rowe's reflections remind us that our understanding of science—and of ourselves in relation to the world—is continually evolving, driven by new discoveries, innovative techniques, and reevaluation of existing knowledge. The complete narrative of the woolly mammoth's extinction is still being written, just as future scientists will explore the chapters of terrestrial extinctions during the Anthropocene, an era defined by our significant impact on the planet's climate and ecosystems.

If you found this article engaging, consider following Aha! for insights into the fascinating science behind life's most intriguing questions. Writers are also invited to explore my Writer’s Guide newsletter—your support enables my reporting and writing endeavors.

Chapter 2: Exploring the Evidence

In the video What Really Happened To the Woolly Mammoths? - Joe Rogan & John Reeves, the hosts delve into the various theories surrounding the extinction of woolly mammoths, discussing the roles of climate change and human activity.

Chapter 3: The Last Mammoths

The video The last of the mammoths | Natural History Museum provides a visual exploration of the final days of woolly mammoths, highlighting the environmental changes they faced and their coexistence with early humans.