Mastering Scientific Explanations: Insights from a Case Study
Written on
Chapter 1: The Importance of Explanatory Journalism
The year 2020 has posed numerous challenges, yet it has also highlighted the value of high-quality science journalism. Reporters have tackled various aspects of Covid-19, including mask mandates, vaccine creation, public health initiatives, and issues within the food industry. Covering such a vast and rapidly changing topic is no small feat, but many talented writers have stepped up to the challenge.
Among the various forms of journalism that emerged during this time, explanatory articles stand out. While the term "explanatory journalism" might seem self-evident, it specifically refers to stories designed to clarify phenomena within a broader context. Instead of merely reporting on "the news," these articles provide essential background information that helps readers understand current events more comprehensively.
Although this type of journalism may lack the glamour associated with breaking news or sensationalized stories, it offers distinct advantages. Explanatory pieces often include educational elements, imparting scientific or historical knowledge. Furthermore, they tend to remain relevant longer than articles focused solely on immediate events.
Creating effective explanatory journalism may appear straightforward—after all, one can simply review existing research on a topic. However, the reality is far more complex. The finest explanatory pieces distill intricate subjects into accessible articles. Authors must not only summarize extensive information but also craft it into a clear and engaging narrative. Talented writers make this process seem effortless.
One standout example during the pandemic is Dr. Katherine Wu's work in the New York Times, particularly her pieces titled "Charting a Coronavirus Infection" and "Charting a Covid-19 Immune Response." The first article, in particular, excels in clarity, directness, and informative content, complemented by striking visuals.
This discussion will examine the qualities that make a scientific explainer effective, focusing specifically on Wu's "Charting a Coronavirus Infection." While familiarity with her article is not necessary for this analysis, it is highly recommended.
Video: A Quick-Start Guide to Writing a Case Study Analysis
This video serves as a practical introduction to crafting a case study analysis, offering useful insights for aspiring writers and communicators.
Section 1.1: Contextual Relevance
Wu skillfully connects her narrative to real-world events, using the heightened media attention surrounding Trump’s Covid diagnosis to enhance her article's relevance. Content associated with prominent news stories naturally garners more interest, and Wu artfully weaves these events into her explanation without sacrificing taste or integrity.
Explanatory journalism shines when it clarifies ongoing events. For example, writing about modern submarine technology may seem intriguing; however, it lacks immediate relevance unless tied to a current incident, such as a submarine accident. In this case, an explainer would not only be timely but also provide context for understanding the situation.
Subsection 1.1.1: Clarity and Simplicity
As Einstein famously stated, "Everything should be made as simple as possible, but no simpler." Wu's writing exemplifies this principle. Her sentences are concise, her sections focused, and she avoids unnecessary jargon. When complex terminology is unavoidable, Wu either explains it briefly or provides links to additional resources. Overall, her aim appears to be writing at a grade 9 or 10 reading level.
Numerical data is also minimal in her work. Day ranges such as "four to five days" are mentioned occasionally, but only one percentage is included at the end. This deliberate choice helps to engage readers who might find statistics daunting.
While not all explanatory journalism requires such simplicity, Wu's approach effectively broadens her audience, making it accessible to those less familiar with Covid-19 science. This trade-off between depth and accessibility is crucial; "Charting a Coronavirus Infection" succeeds in reaching both casual readers and those deeply interested in the topic.
Section 1.2: The Role of Visuals
Acknowledging the collaborative effort behind Wu's article is essential, as Jonathan Corum played a significant role in creating its visuals. These graphics complement Wu's straightforward text, presenting information in a clean and appealing manner.
A key feature of these visuals is their incremental complexity. Starting with basic concepts, they gradually introduce more intricate ideas, allowing readers to build understanding progressively. This mirrors the purpose of explanatory journalism: beginning with foundational knowledge and layering on complexity over time.
Interestingly, these "charts" defy traditional graphing conventions—they lack labeled axes, numerical values, and error ranges. While these omissions may be seen as weaknesses in technical contexts, they serve a greater purpose here: making the information accessible to a broader audience.