Exploring the Complexities of Racial Identity and Experience
Written on
Chapter 1: The Quest for Understanding Racial Experience
Two summers ago, author Sam Forster set out on a nationwide journey, donning a disguise to present himself as a Black man in an attempt to capture the realities of racism in America. His forthcoming memoir, titled "Seven Shoulders," which recounts this experience, has sparked significant debate due to its controversial premise. While some may commend Forster's ambition to understand the Black experience, this approach reduces blackness to a mere disguise, dismissing the complexity of racial identity as something that can be worn and removed at will. This method not only appears insensitive but also fails to provide a genuine insight into the realities faced by Black individuals in the United States.
In Shakespeare's "The Tempest," it is suggested that past experiences shape our present, a sentiment echoed in the context of Forster's social experiment. His actions draw parallels to John Howard Griffin's 1961 work "Black Like Me," in which Griffin traveled through the Jim Crow South disguised as a Black man to document his findings on systemic racism. Griffin, who altered his skin color and appearance, expressed a desire to reveal the harsh truths of a segregated society. He believed that by experiencing life as a Black man, he could foster empathy and awareness regarding discrimination. Despite the book's massive success, selling over ten million copies, it does not hold a candle to the narratives crafted by Black authors who have shared their lived experiences.
Griffin's journey ignited his passion for social justice, originating from his experiences in a French boarding school where he first encountered the segregation of races. His involvement in aiding Jewish children during World War II placed him on a Nazi death list, showcasing his commitment to fighting injustice. However, Griffin’s exploration as a disguised Black man ultimately fell short, as he could easily shed his disguise, a privilege not afforded to actual Black individuals. Racism, unlike a costume, is a permanent and painful reality.
From a social research perspective, it might seem reasonable to replicate Griffin's study to explore potential differences in experiences today. Yet, the ethical implications of such a replication are questionable. The act of blackening one's skin and adopting physical traits associated with Black individuals is rooted in a troubling history of blackface, making it an inherently racist practice. It also fails to recognize that blackness encompasses cultural and experiential dimensions far beyond mere appearance.
Griffin's memoir did not adequately address the nuances of language used within the Black community, such as African American Vernacular English (AAVE) and Black American Sign Language, which are integral to understanding Black identity. Forster, as a Canadian-American writer, likely lacks a deep understanding of these aspects, highlighting a gap in his approach to conveying the Black experience. This raises the question of who is best suited to articulate these narratives—those who live them or those who attempt to adopt them.
The backlash against Forster's memoir reflects a broader sentiment: Black individuals are the most qualified to share their own stories. There is a wealth of literature—books, essays, poems, and films—produced by Black creators that offer profound insights into their experiences. Yet, the notion persists that a White individual who adopts a Black persona might be viewed as a more credible voice on racism, demonstrating a troubling tendency toward racially selective empathy.
This pattern reveals that even in the quest for racial equity, some White individuals may inadvertently undermine their efforts. Griffin noted the resistance faced by those advocating for justice, expressing a desire for a society that lives up to its promises of equality. However, his use of blackface has drawn criticism, especially from those he sought to uplift.
As we anticipate the release of Forster's "Seven Shoulders," we must ask ourselves: Why resort to a disguise to understand racism when countless Black voices exist, ready to share their stories? The preference for narratives written by White individuals often stems from a reluctance to accept the authenticity of Black experiences. This bias perpetuates a cycle where the true narratives of Black individuals are overlooked in favor of those who mimic their experiences.
One of the most effective ways to understand a group’s experiences is through direct engagement—interviewing individuals, asking thoughtful questions, and allowing them to shape the narrative. Unfortunately, many White individuals still shy away from these conversations or focus on their own perspectives, neglecting the voices that truly matter. While "Seven Shoulders" may receive praise reminiscent of "Black Like Me," it is crucial to recognize the limitations of bypassing the essential practice of listening to Black individuals. The potential insights gained from valuing their narratives far outweigh the understanding achieved through appropriation.
The first video titled "The Oprah Winfrey Show: Black for A Day" dives into the complexities of identity and race, exploring the repercussions of adopting a different racial identity.
In the second video, a White journalist discusses his experience of disguising himself as a Black man to write about racism, shedding light on the ethical implications of such actions.