# A Unique Interview Experience: When Casual Meets Professionalism
Written on
Chapter 1: The Final Interview Day
Today marks the conclusion of our lengthy interview process at the consulting firm where I work. As a middle manager, I was tasked with hiring analysts, and it has been a rigorous journey, spanning several months. The selection process is layered: team leads conduct the first round, followed by HR managers for the second, and finally, the hiring managers evaluate the candidates in the last round. Out of 25 applicants, only one would make it to my desk.
Section 1.1: A Surprising Arrival
When I saw Frank walk in, my expectations were quickly shattered. I struggled to maintain my composure as my mind raced with thoughts. Frank's outfit—a polo shirt, cropped jeans, and a Snoopy tie—was nothing short of startling. It took me a moment to gather myself as I greeted him.
"Thank you for joining us today. Would you like some iced water?" I offered, hoping for a standard exchange.
To my surprise, Frank simply extended his fist for a bump instead of offering a handshake. I couldn't help but feel out of touch at 40, but I rolled with it. "Sure, iced water it is!" he replied enthusiastically.
Section 1.2: The Snoopy Tie
I couldn't shake off the distraction of Frank's tie, which prominently featured the cartoon dog. It was a bold choice, one that occupied the majority of his outfit's visual space. As much as I wanted to focus on his qualifications, I found myself fixated on the tie's absurdity.
"Why did you choose to wear this?" James, my colleague, eventually asked.
Frank beamed and explained, "This tie symbolizes my victory in the Grand Award at the Regional Cosplay Competition. Today is just as important, so I wanted to bring some of that spirit here!"
Chapter 2: Unexpected Revelations
Frank eagerly pulled out his phone to show us photos from the event, excitedly recounting his experiences. I was taken aback by his enthusiasm, which felt out of place in an interview setting. I was beginning to think I might need a break.
"Excuse me, I need to step out for a moment," I said, feeling overwhelmed.
James, recognizing my predicament, expressed his own surprise at the situation.
The Unfolding Drama
Returning to the interview, I realized my gut was telling me that I was seeking an analyst, not a performer. As the interview wrapped up, I posed a crucial question: "What motivates you to pursue a career in consulting, and why should I consider hiring you?"
Frank's response was perplexing at best: "Consulting is akin to cosplay competitions. It requires skill, stage presence, and the ability to engage an audience, and I'm confident in my abilities."
His comparison left me speechless, and an awkward silence filled the room.
James eventually informed Frank that he would receive updates about his application status. Frank stood, adjusted his tie, and extended his fist once more, exclaiming, "Till All Are One!"
I complied, giving him a bump, albeit weakly, as I wanted him to leave.
The Aftermath
Am I out of touch? Have I lost my grasp on current societal norms? Perhaps. While I respect individual expression, I do believe professionalism should prevail in business settings. A formal shirt and slacks would suffice in creating a positive impression.
Frank's choice of attire, while reflective of his personality, was not something I felt was appropriate for the workplace. A simple tie—perhaps in a muted color—would create a better impression. Is that too much to ask?
Like this story? Don't forget to subscribe! And if you're feeling generous, a cup of black coffee would be much appreciated!