A Grieving Mother Receives a Message from Her Daughter's Ghost
Written on
Chapter 1: The Mysterious Death of Elva Zona Heaster Shue
The story unfolds in a West Virginia cemetery, where a plaque reads:
“Interred in a nearby cemetery is Zona Heaster Shue. Her death in 1897 was presumed natural until her spirit appeared to her mother to describe how she was killed. It’s the only known case in which testimony from a ghost helped convict a murderer.” This is the haunting tale of Elva Zona Heaster Shue.
Elva and Erasmus Stribbling Trout Shue had been married for a while. Their romance blossomed quickly; Elva, in her twenties, was known for her beautiful dark hair and charming personality, while Erasmus, a tall and attractive blacksmith in his thirties, was deeply in love with her. Despite her family's disapproval, particularly from her mother, Mary Jane Heaster, Elva was determined to be with Erasmus.
As they settled into a quaint home in Greenbrier County, excitement filled the air when Elva became pregnant. However, complications arose, prompting the couple to delay sharing the news with their loved ones.
On January 23, 1897, Erasmus intended to leave work early to check on Elva, but a large shoe order kept him late. He dispatched his assistant to visit her and see if she needed anything from the market. Upon arrival, the assistant knocked but received no response. Concerned, he forced open the unlocked door and stepped into darkness.
Elva Was Found Unresponsive
Inside, the assistant discovered Elva lying motionless at the foot of the stairs, her position suggesting sleep. Calling her name yielded no reply. Frantic, he rushed home to inform his mother, who immediately contacted the local doctor. When the doctor finally arrived, Erasmus had already taken Elva upstairs, prepared her for burial, and was mourning her loss.
The doctor concluded that Elva likely passed away due to pregnancy complications. Her funeral took place the following day, with Erasmus grief-stricken. As he dressed her in a beloved scarf that clashed with her burial attire, Mary Jane glared at him with disdain.
Mary Jane's Strange Behavior
Days after the burial, Mary Jane exhibited unusual behavior. She isolated herself, neglecting her appearance and pacing through the night. On a particular February morning, she emerged looking surprisingly composed, only to storm into the office of the local prosecutor, John Preston, to recount a shocking tale about her deceased daughter.
Initially, John believed Mary Jane was losing her sanity. However, intrigued, he consulted the doctor who had examined Elva’s body. The doctor noted he hadn’t inspected Elva's neck and head. Upon attempting to do so, Erasmus became visibly upset, causing the doctor to dismiss any foul play.
As doubts lingered, John became convinced that Mary Jane's claims warranted further investigation. They exhumed Elva's body to conduct a thorough examination.
Mary Jane's Desperate Plea
Determined to get answers, Mary Jane fervently prayed for her daughter’s spirit to appear. One night, her prayers were answered when a bright light filled her room, and Elva's ghost emerged, dressed in black and looking eerily pale. Initially frightened, Mary Jane quickly regained her composure and asked how Elva had died.
Elva revealed that while Erasmus seemed kind, he was, in fact, abusive. On the day of her death, he had violently attacked her over a dinner dispute, ultimately breaking her neck. After sharing this chilling account, Elva turned to leave, casting a haunting glance back at her mother.
The Investigation Leads to Arrest
Following the re-examination of Elva’s remains, the doctor discovered clear signs of foul play: bruising on her neck and evidence that her windpipe had been crushed. This led to the arrest of Erasmus for murder. Although no clear motive was established, he was convicted and sentenced to life impri